The Man Who Wouldn't Die (1942) - Rotten Tomatoes

The Man Who Wouldn't Die1942

The Man Who Wouldn't Die (1942)





Critic Consensus: No consensus yet.

The Man Who Wouldn't Die Photos

Movie Info

In this mystery, a millionaire hires a detective to learn the identity of the man who threatens to kill him and his daughter. The gumshoe begins impersonating the daughter's husband and learns that his wife is involved with an unhinged Hindu who is supposed to be dead.


Lloyd Nolan
as Michael Shayne
Marjorie Weaver
as Catherine Wolff
Helene Reynolds
as Anne Wolff
Henry Wilcoxon
as Dr. Haggard
Richard Derr
as Roger Blake
Paul Harvey
as Dudley Wolff
Olin Howland
as Chief Meek
Billy Bevan
as Phillips, the Butler
Robert Emmett Keane
as Alfred Dunning
LeRoy Mason
as Zorah Bey
Jeff Corey
as Coroner Larson
Francis Ford
as Caretaker
View All

Critic Reviews for The Man Who Wouldn't Die

There are no critic reviews yet for The Man Who Wouldn't Die. Keep checking Rotten Tomatoes for updates!

Audience Reviews for The Man Who Wouldn't Die

A young woman awakens at night to see a man with glowing eyes staring at her. This man shoots at her but misses and when she tells others, there's no evidence she was there! They act as if it's some sort of dream, but she's sure it isn't. Now how Michael Shayne gets involved is pretty odd. This same woman later meets him along the road and asks him to pose as her husband. She is apparently married but wants to pass Shayne off as her new husband. None of this made sense--why didn't she just bring her real husband? Why didn't she just tell people that he was a private detective--especially when he found the bullet shot at her--proving someone DID shoot at her! Odd indeed! In the midst of this mystery, a man takes off from the mansion and is chased by Shayne and the police chief. The car crashes and the man is thrown. The chief very quickly pronounces him dead. Inexplicably, the body disappears later! Was he really dead or did someone steal the corpse? This is all getting very strange and confusing (especially for the audience), as there are lots and lots of seemingly divergent plot points in the film. Supposedly, this is all related somehow to some strange magician, Zorah Bey. This is an enjoyable Michael Shayne film, mostly due to the seemingly relaxed performance by Lloyd Nolan as Shayne. However, the story is a tad confusing and seems to perhaps have too many twists and turns...but it never is dull. For lovers of B-detective films, this one is certainly worth finding. 5 stars

Bruce Bruce
Bruce Bruce

Super Reviewer

The Man Who Wouldn't Die Quotes

There are no approved quotes yet for this movie.

News & Features